Over the last 3 years, we have been working towards integrating Habits of Mind into our curriculum. We’ve had some successes but it’s been a challenge to maintain the momentum. Is it another layer to add to the curriculum and thus more work to do? Have we embraced its philosophy? Or is it a case of teachers needing to accept to what extent they have good or bad habits themselves? As I’ve posted earlier this year, I am a big believer in teachers being role models in learning. Maybe, as teachers and learners ourselves, we ( and I’m referring to teachers as a whole, not just myself or my colleagues) have to reflect earnestly on how developed our own Habits of Mind are before we can truly embed them into our curriculum. How can we expect our students to develop good Habits if we haven’t ourselves?
With sixteen official Habits of Mind as outlined by their “creator”, Art Costa, this would become an extremely long post, even by my rather wordy standards. I’m going to split my reflections into several posts, using the S.U.C.C.E.S.S categories shown in the image above. Today, I’ll focus on the “Control” Habits.
As a learner;– do you consciously make an effort to stay on task during meetings, PD sessions etc, when the content is dry, irrelevant or “boring” so that you are still focused when something enlightening, useful or interesting is shared? OR… do you just tune out like that frustrating student in your class who never listens to you?
– do you recognize your struggle in understanding a new pedagogy, concept, educational framework and look for alternative methods of learning until you have developed a level of comprehension you are satisfied with? OR… do you just claim you’ve never been good at that subject and never will be so avoid it like that student in your class you always complain doesn’t try hard enough?
As a teacher;– do you allow your students enough opportunities to re-submit work until they have shown they have grasped the understanding both you and them were aim for? OR… do you reinforce the idea that assessment is a ‘sink or swim’, one chance or you fail opportunity to prove you learnt something?
– do you provide enough time for students to struggle, problem solve, collaborate on solutions, challenge conjectures and answers? OR… do you jump in with the answer so you can move on to your next planned lesson, thereby teaching them that you are the source of all knowledge so its not worth persisting?
– do your students see you working on problems you don’t have the answer to, trying a variety of methods to achieve success, tackling complex problems over a number of days OR… do they only see you present the answers to everything?
- prepare and follow a plan for completing the set task?
- take in all information?
- listen to all points of view?
- weigh up all the evidence (both pros and cons)?
- reflect on your emotional and logical response to what has been presented?
- re read, listen to or review notes (written or audio)?
- ask clarifying questions?
- investigate/consult alternative sources of information or opinions?
- And then act
As a teacher; Do you have a set of procedures to follow that allow you to manage challenging behaviour in the classroom rationally and consistently OR… do you react inconsistently to inappropriate behaviour thereby giving students mixed messages about expectations in the classroom?
Do you rehearse possible answers to possible scenarios/questions that may arise during challenging/controversial discussions/lesson sequences OR… do you just react insitinctively to students’ questions without knowing the consequences of your answers and so modelling to the children that its acceptable to say anything?
Do you have a culture of “wait time” in the room so children are comfortable with taking time to record ideas or collaborate with others before they respond to questions OR… is it a competition to be the first to answer a question or do you jump in to answer the question before any student gets a chance to?
Taking responsible risks
- Investigate new apps and programs without help, discovering functions by experimenting with menu options and icons?
- Trial all possible strategies in Mathematics over a long period of time to find out which strategies work best in different situations?
- Experiment with new skills and activities you have never attempted to see if you can master them at a level you are comfortable with?
As a teacher;
Do you –
- expose yourself as a learner who needs to find out how to do something in front of the class?
- make mistakes in front of the students and look for solutions on the spot rather than making sure everything is perfect in your lesson?
- Provide opportunities for students to engage in problem solving that requires testing out multiple possibilities?
- Encourage students to try out many strategies even when they are not competent or comfortable with them so they can become more accomplished at using them?
- Experiment with newly advertised pedagogies over an extended period of time to give them time to show evidence of improved learning?
Now don’t get me wrong. I’m no perfect role model either. While I am persistent and like to experiment, I don’t necessarily go outside my comfort zone much ( although it is a wide ranging zone in most mainstream classroom – in my extension programs, my students see me struggle) and I still have my days when I don’t follow a consistent management plan. the point of this reflection is to challenge the teaching community to analyse their own “habits of mind’ before expecting children to just develop them. Practise what you preach. The Habits aren’t just some content to learn about. They have to become part of your being. We have to make sure they’re part of OUR being.
Next Post: Part Two – Cognitive (past knowledge/metacognition/questioning and problem solving